We Don’t Need Their Approval
The world has changed dramatically since the days of Avrohom, Yitzchok, and Yaakov. Empires have risen and fallen. Civilizations have flourished and disappeared. Kings and rulers who once commanded the destinies of millions have been relegated to the pages of history. The world has become more sophisticated, more educated, more technologically advanced, and, at least outwardly, more civilized.
But the forces that confronted
our forefathers continue to confront us, albeit in different forms, dressed in
different clothing and speaking different languages.
We sometimes forget that. We are
impressed by Eisov. He is polished, sophisticated, and articulate. He dresses
impeccably, speaks beautifully, knows how to make people feel comfortable, and
presents himself as a man of peace and goodwill. We are flattered when he
extends his hand in friendship and assures us that he wants nothing more than
to live alongside us in harmony.
But then, as happened recently,
the mask slips, the hostility re-emerges, and we are shocked. How can it be?
How could this happen? How could people who speak so warmly about tolerance and
acceptance turn against us? How could advanced societies become breeding
grounds for antisemitism?
The answer is that the external
trappings of civilization do not necessarily change the nature of Eisov. He can
be educated and cultured, articulate and charming, and still harbor deep
resentment toward us. And these days, there are plenty of people who epitomize
that. Think of the people who openly campaigned against Israel, a code word for
Jews, and of all the people who voted for open antisemites, and you may start
wondering how long the American dream will last.
We had thought we were safe here
and that it would be different here, and then suddenly we recognize that the
lessons of Sefer Bereishis are as relevant today as they were thousands
of years ago.
Avrohom and Yitzchok were
wealthy, generous, and peaceful. Nevertheless, their neighbors fought them and
sought to drive them away.
In this week’s parsha,
Yaakov Avinu encounters an adversary whose hostility is concealed beneath the
guise of familial affection. Lovon was his uncle, his father-in-law, and his
employer, a man who owed much of his prosperity to Yaakov, yet he repaid twenty
years of extraordinary devotion with deception, exploitation, and betrayal.
Lovon deceived Yaakov in
marriage, repeatedly altered his wages, and took advantage of his integrity.
Yet when Yaakov finally departed at Hashem’s command, Lovon pursued him with
righteous indignation, casting himself as the injured party. The deceiver became
the accuser, the exploiter the victim, and the man who had suffered the
injustice was suddenly called upon to defend himself.
It is a familiar inversion, one
that resonates painfully in our own time.
Israel was subjected to a
barbaric assault by Hamas terrorists, who massacred innocent civilians,
abducted hostages, and unleashed a war upon the Jewish state. Yet when Israel
fought back to defend its citizens and prevent another massacre, much of the world’s
outrage shifted from those who perpetrated the atrocities to those who had
suffered them.
The country that was attacked
found itself accused of genocide. Its products became targets of boycotts, its
leaders faced international condemnation, and governments moved to restrict
military assistance. The atrocities that precipitated the war receded from the
discussion, while Israel’s response became the overriding moral offense.
Lovon’s great deception was not
simply that he mistreated Yaakov. It was that he claimed the moral authority to
condemn the very man he had mistreated.
The passage of thousands of years
has done little to diminish the appeal of that maneuver. The language has
become more sophisticated, the accusations more elaborate, and the forums more
prestigious. But the underlying inversion remains: Those who initiate violence
against the Jewish people are excused or forgotten, while the Jews who resist
it are called upon to justify their very right to defend themselves.
Even Lovon’s name, meaning white,
suggested purity and innocence. He cloaked his dishonesty in righteousness,
presenting his self-interest as moral indignation. It is an art that has lost
none of its practitioners over the centuries.
The enduring lesson of the story
lies not only in Lovon’s duplicity, but in Yaakov’s response.
Yaakov did not become a Lovon in
order to survive Lovon.
Twenty years of mistreatment did
not diminish his integrity or divert him from his mission. He refused to allow
the injustice he had suffered to define his character or determine his destiny.
While Lovon schemed to accumulate
wealth and exercise control, Yaakov quietly built something infinitely more
enduring: the family from which Klal Yisroel would emerge.
Lovon measured success by what he
could acquire. Yaakov measured it by what he could transmit.
Lovon was consumed with
possessing the present. Yaakov was laying the foundations of the future, of
eternity.
And when their paths finally
separated, Lovon became a footnote in the story of Yaakov, while Yaakov became
the father of a nation whose destiny would transcend the ages.
There is another lesson in
Yaakov’s encounter with Lovon. Our strength has never depended upon winning the
approval of others or conforming to the values of the societies around us. We
have endured precisely because we remained faithful to the Torah and the
mission entrusted to us by our forefathers.
In every generation, the Jewish
people have been confronted with essentially the same proposition, dressed in
the language of the times and presented a little differently. It always boiled
down to the entreaty that if we would just abandon what makes us different and
adapt to their ways, we would be accepted.
And in every generation, there
have been Jews who believed the promise.
Seeking acceptance and
respectability, they gradually adopted the standards of the surrounding
culture, until they came to view their heritage through the eyes of those who
disparaged it. They dismissed what has sustained the Jewish people through
centuries of exile as obstacles to progress. They abandoned the traditions of
their forefathers and began to look down upon those who remained faithful to
them.
And then they found out the hard
way that the world of Eisov cares as little for us when we adapt ourselves to
fit in with them as it does when we remain loyal to Torah. The Jews who seek
recognition from the big world are shocked when that world mocks, vilifies, and
curses them. They are shocked when universities, professors, and fellow
students turn on them and march against them. They cannot accept it when their
favorite political party promotes people who hate them and demotes those who
maintain a semblance of a connection to Israel.
That is one of the great lessons
of our parsha.
Our strength has never depended
upon our ability to imitate the Eisovs and Lovons. Our survival has never been
assured by the approval of the powerful or the admiration of the fashionable.
We have endured because we remained faithful to the mission entrusted to us by
the avos.
Yet those who have distanced
themselves from that inheritance lecture us here and in Eretz Yisroel about how
to live.
They speak in the language of
tolerance, progress, equality, and enlightenment, but have remarkably little
tolerance for Jews whose lives revolve around Torah. They demand respect for
every identity and every lifestyle, yet refuse to extend that same respect and
acceptance to those who adhere to the traditions of their own people.
And when Torah Jews decline to
conform to their expectations, they are portrayed as extremists, fanatics, or
obstacles to the future.
They look at the children of
Yaakov and see a people who have failed to keep pace with the outside world.
They do not realize that the
children of Yaakov are still here precisely because they never permitted the
outside world, in any of its earlier forms, to determine who they were supposed
to be.
New York Times op-ed
columnist Thomas L. Friedman wrote last week, in a scathing column against
Binyomin Netanyahu, whom he criticized, among other things, for castigating the
left for attempting to form a government propped up with support from Arab
parties: “This Israeli Arab community has been 100 times more loyal to the
state of Israel than the ultra-Orthodox fanatics, who over decades have milked
billions of shekels in subsidies from the state for their schools, which don’t
teach modern subjects, and who refuse to serve in the Israeli army to defend
their fellow Jews.”
Thomas Friedman has written many
outrageous things about Israel over the years, but his latest attack on the chareidi
community reveals a particularly breathtaking contempt for the very people who
have preserved the Jewish nation throughout its long and painful history.
In Friedman’s upside-down world,
Jews who dedicate their lives to studying Hashem’s Torah, observing His
commandments, and transmitting our sacred heritage to the next generation are
dangerous fanatics who contribute less to Israel than communities whose
political representatives do not even accept the Zionist definition of the
state.
Think about the absurdity of that
argument.
For thousands of years, long
before there was an Israeli government, an IDF, a Knesset, or a national
budget, there were Jews learning Torah. There were fathers teaching their sons,
rabbonim teaching their talmidim, and generations sacrificing
their comfort, their livelihoods, and sometimes their lives rather than abandon
their allegiance to Hashem.
It was that devotion that
preserved the Jewish people through the destruction of the Botei Mikdosh,
the Roman persecutions, the Crusades, the Inquisition, the pogroms, and the
Holocaust.
The chareidi community is
not an accidental appendage to the Jewish state. It is the continuation of the
way the Jewish people have lived for millennia.
Yet Friedman has the audacity to
characterize these Jews as parasites because their educational institutions
place Torah above other studies and because their understanding of national
responsibility differs from his.
To transform those disagreements
about military exemptions, government funding, and educational policy into an
indictment of an entire religious community, and to suggest that devotion to
Torah constitutes disloyalty to the Jewish state, is something altogether
different.
Friedman praises the
contributions of Israeli Arab doctors, nurses, and pharmacists. But
professional service, however admirable, is not the same as political
allegiance to Israel’s identity as a Jewish state.
Nor does his argument address the
fundamental contradiction in demanding that chareidi Jews prove their
loyalty through military service while treating the absence of military service
among most Israeli Arabs as no impediment to his sweeping declaration of their
superior loyalty.
There are Israeli Arabs who have
demonstrated extraordinary courage and loyalty, including those who have served
in the security forces, saved Jewish lives, and condemned Hamas terrorism. That
deserves recognition. But there are also political movements that oppose
Israel’s Jewish national identity, and their positions cannot simply be ignored
because Friedman and his friends on the left find them politically useful.
Indeed, the central question is
not whether an Arab citizen can be loyal to Israel. The question is how
Friedman can confidently proclaim an entire community more loyal than the Jews
who have dedicated their lives to preserving the Torah and Jewish identity.
And there is an even deeper
irony.
Friedman seems to believe that
Israel’s legitimacy and survival depend exclusively upon the institutions of
the modern state. He overlooks that the Jewish people’s connection to Eretz
Yisroel was established thousands of years before modern Zionism. It was
preserved through the Torah, through our tefillos, through our longing
for Yerushalayim, and through the unwavering faith of generations who refused
to forget who they were.
The yeshivos are not
obstacles to Jewish continuity. They are its greatest guardians.
Friedman is entitled to disagree
with their political positions. He is entitled to advocate changes in
government policy. But he is not entitled to rewrite Jewish history or pretend
that those who have devoted their lives to its preservation are somehow enemies
of the Jewish people.
The Jewish people did not survive
for thousands of years to be told that the Jews who continue living by the
Torah that sustained them are the ones betraying their nation.
Israel needs its soldiers. It
needs its doctors, its scientists, and its workers. And it needs its lomdei
Torah, its yeshivos, and its rabbonim.
A Jewish state that forgets the
value of Torah has forgotten something far more fundamental than the political
calculations of Thomas Friedman. It has forgotten what made it Jewish in the
first place.
And let us not forget another
fundamental truth. Israel was established as a Jewish state, a homeland for the
Jewish people, rooted in thousands of years of Jewish history, Jewish faith,
and Jewish attachment to Eretz Yisroel. Its very claim to the land rests upon
the Jewish people’s G-d-given connection to it, a connection preserved through
the Torah, our tefillos, and the unwavering devotion of generations of
faithful Jews. Without that history, without the Torah that sustained our
people through centuries of exile, what distinguishes Israel from any other
country? How extraordinary, then, that Friedman would portray the very Jews who
most faithfully preserve those foundations as less loyal to the Jewish state
than those who reject its Jewish national character.
Israel was created to provide a
home where Jews could live as Jews and perpetuate their heritage. Yet the
leftists would have us believe that those who devote their lives to precisely
those purposes are the ones undermining the state. What a remarkable inversion
of the very reason for its existence.
The lesson of this week’s parsha
is as relevant today as it was when Yaakov Avinu stood before Lovon.
Yaakov did not seek Lovon’s
approval. He did not measure his worth by Lovon’s standards. He did not abandon
his principles to earn his father-in-law’s respect or convince him that he was
worthy of acceptance. He knew who he was, where he came from, and where he was
going.
And that is why Yaakov prevailed.
We also need not apologize for
our devotion to Torah, for the sacrifices we make to raise our children in its
ways, or for our determination to preserve the traditions that have sustained
our people through the centuries. We need not seek validation from those who
judge us according to standards foreign to our heritage.
We should conduct ourselves with
dignity, honesty, and kindness, treating others with respect and demonstrating
through our actions the beauty of a Torah life. We must never allow hostility
to make us hostile, or contempt to diminish our own commitment to middos
tovos. But neither may we permit the criticism of others, however prominent
or influential they may be, to weaken our convictions.
The world has produced countless
Nimrods, Lovons, and Eisovs. They have appeared in different generations,
wearing different clothing and speaking different languages. Some confronted us
with open hostility, while others assured us that they only sought our welfare.
Some demanded that we abandon our faith, while others insisted that we merely
modernize it, dilute it, or adjust it to conform to the prevailing wisdom of
the day.
But Yaakov is still here. His
children gather in botei medrash to study the same words that sustained
their ancestors. They welcome the Shabbos with the same kedusha,
raise their children with the same hopes, and turn to the same Ribbono Shel
Olam with the same emunah and bitachon.
The world has changed beyond
recognition, but the flame kindled by Avrohom, guarded by Yitzchok, and carried
forward by Yaakov continues to burn and is being carried forward, day after
day, by the very people whom some would have us believe are an embarrassment to
the Jewish nation.
Think of the irony. Those who
have devoted their lives to preserving the inheritance of our forefathers are
being lectured about Jewish loyalty by people who fail to appreciate that
inheritance and betray it in every form possible.
For the ultimate answer to those
who disparage the Torah world is not found in newspaper columns, political
arguments, or public declarations. It is found in the excitement of a child
being given their first siddur, in the devotion of a father rising early
to learn before beginning his day, and in the sacrifices of people who dedicate
their lives to Torah. It is found in the people who ignore the outside noise
and static, if they are even aware of it, and do what Jews have been doing for
thousands of years wherever they have been, answering the call of Hashem and
proclaiming, “Naaseh v’nishma.” We will follow the Torah and the mesorah,
and nothing else.
That is our answer. That is our
strength. That is our future.
The world will continue to
change. New leaders will rise, new philosophies will become fashionable, and
new voices will tell us that our ways are not relevant. But every year on Chanukah,
we will continue lighting the menorah, which reminds us of how we stood
up to the efforts to assimilate us into Hellenist culture and how Hashem
empowered us, allowing us to overcome the forces that sought to subvert us.
Lovon may have had the upper hand
for twenty years, and there were times when Eisov appeared to dominate, but
neither was able to extinguish the light of Yaakov. They couldn’t do it then.
They cannot do it now. And they never will be able to. Not them and not any of
their inheritors. Ad ki yavo leTzion goel bemeheirah beyomeinu.
